National Council for Teacher Education

ER–105.4(I).26	Sunil Dhar Memorial B.P.Ed. College, Vill + PO: Panchthupi, P.S. : Burdwan, Block-Burdwan, Dist:Murshidabad, West Bengal – 742161 (B.P.Ed) (University of Kalyani) Code No. APE00669	The Committee considered the case of the institution along with relevant documents, NCTE Act, Regulations 2007 and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time and decided that action as per the appellate authority order to be initiated.
ER–105.4(I).27	L.P. Shahi Institute of Teacher Education, Vill – Dighra, Ps –Town, Dist. – Muzaffarpur, Bihar – 842001 (B.Ed) (Private) (B.R.A. Bihar University) (Code No.APE00973)	The Committee considered the reply received in this office on 08.03.2010 in response to ERC Notice dt.08.01.2010 along with relevant documents, NCTE Act, Regulations 2007 and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time and decided that Notice u/s 14(3) (b) may be issued giving 30 days for the following deficiencies. (i) Total area not mentioned in the building completion certificate. (ii) Total area not mentioned in the building plan. (iii) List of teaching staff not submitted in prescribed format. (iv) The Mandatory Disclosure Format (MDF) to uploaded on the website not submitted. (v) Experience certificate of Principal not submitted and not submitted the other certificates. (vi) One lecturer i.e. Daya Shankar Pandey not qualified as per norms.
ER–105.4(I).28	Ratulia Secondary Teachers Training Institute, Panskura Vidyasagar Social Welfare Society Building, Vill.- Kanakpur, Po.- Naranda, Dist.- Purba Medinipur, West Bengal- 721 139 (B.Ed) (Private) (Vidyasagar University) (Code No.APE00573)	The Committee considered the case of the institution along with relevant documents, NCTE Act, Regulations 2007 and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time and decided that letter of intent u/s 7(9) as per NCTE Regulations 2007 may be issued as per appellate authority order.
ER–105.4(I).29	Sonargaon Vivekananda Institute for Primary Teachers’ Training Institute, Teghoria, NARENDRAPUR, Stn. Road, PO – R.K. Pally, PS – Sonarpur, Dist- Kolkata, West Bengal- 700 150 (PTT)(D.Ed), (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (Code No.APE00655)	The Committee considered the case of the institution along with relevant documents, NCTE Act, Regulations 2007 and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time and decided that letter of intent u/s 7(9) as per NCTE Regulations 2007 may be issued as per appellate authority order.
ER–105.4(I).30	Dr. Ambedkar Hindi Sanskrit Vidyapeeth Bihar Cum Education & Training, Vill – Jokia, PO – Joika, Dist – Begusarai, Bihar – 851127 (B.T.C) (Hindi University, Allahabad) Code No. APE00944	The Committee considered the reply dt.01.02.2010 received in this office on 10.02.2010 in response to ERC letter of intent dt.08.01.2010 along with relevant documents, NCTE Act, Regulations 2007 and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time and decided that Notice u/s 14(3) (b) may be issued giving 30 days for the following deficiencies. (i) Requisite no. of teaching staff not qualified as per NCTE norms. Also Principal not qualified as per norms and experience certificate not given. (ii) Downloaded copy of the mandatory disclosure format not submitted. (iii) Download copy of the website is not submitted. (iv) The website of the institution is verified and found functioning however it has not shown in the affidavit of teaching staff on Rs.10/- stamp paper & Rs. 100/- stamp paper regarding selection committee.
ER–103.4(II)	Appeal Cases: Cases Rejected by the Appeal Committee and confirmed the ERC order.
ER–103.4(II).1	Bhagawan Budh Primary Teacher’s Education College, Vill/PO. – Bajrahian, PS – Gautam Budh Nagar, Via – Maharaj Ganj, Dist – Siwan, Bihar – 841238 (BTC) (Bihar School Examination Board) (Code No.APE00821)	The Committee noted that the appeal was rejected and the ERC’s order dated 26.10.2009 was confirmed.
ER–103.4(II).2	Repeated
ER–103.4(II).3	Kendrapara Autonomous College, Twon – Kendrapara, Po- Kendrapara, Dist- Kendrapara, Orissa – 754211 (B.P.Ed.) (Utkal University) (Code No.APE01065)	The Committee noted that the appeal was rejected and the ERC’s order dated 05.08.2009 was confirmed.
ER-105.7	Court Case
ER-105.7.1	Surendra B.Ed. Teachers Training College, Surendra nagar, Shiwala More, Khagul, Patna, Bihar – 800001, Code No. APE00521, B.Ed., Private.	The Eastern Regional Committee noted that the authorized person of the institution has not appeared, however since he has appeared on 23^rd Feb, 2010, when the meeting was postponed. He should be given another opportunity in the next meeting and the office may intimate the institution accordingly.
ER–105.9	Miscellaneous Cases
ER–105.9.1	Krishnapur Primary Teacher’s Training Institute, Vill/Po- Krishnapur, Po- Nalhati, Dist- Birbhum, West Bengal – 731237 (D.Ed) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (Code No.APE0620)	Deferred for the next ERC meeting for thorough examination by the office.
ER–105.9.2	Vinaya Bhavan, Deptt. Of Education, Visva Bharati, Santi Niketan, Birbhum, West Bengal (B.Ed) (University Department) (Visva Bharati University) (Code No.APE00008 (New)	The Committee considered the reply letter dt.01.02.2010 received on ERC dt.08.02.2010 in response to ERC Notice dt. 08.01.2010 along with relevant documents, NCTE Act, Regulations 2007 and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time and decided that recognition may be withdrawn from the next academic session i.e. 2010-2011 for the following deficiencies :- · The institution was granted recognition for an intake of 200 students. The institution has admitted 272 students in 2009-2010 and 236 in 2008-09 which is more than permitted intake. · Required number of teaching staff for 200 intake are not appointed. It has appointed Guest lecturers in place of regular staff which is not as per NCTE norms. · Affidavit on Rs. 10/- stamp paper by Head and the teaching staff alongwith the marksheet and certificate not submitted.
ER–105.9.3	Rajkumar Sanatombi Devi College, T. Line, North A.O.C., Imphal East, Manipur-795001 (Private) (B.Ed) (Code No.APE00250).	The Committee noted that a complaint dt.18.09.2009 Received in ERC on 30.09.2009 and decided that comments from the institution be sought on the complaint received.
ER–105.9.4	Dainhata Joy Maa Tara PTTI, Dainhat Subhas Road, Dist - Burdwan, West Bengal – 713 502 (PTT) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (Private) (Code No.APE00922)	The Committee noted that a complaint dt.07.01.2010 Received in ERC on 30.09.2009 and decided that comments from the institution be sought on the complaint received.
ER–105.9.5	Shifting of Premises and change of Name of the institution viz. Doying Gumin College, PO- Pasighat, East Siang, Dist-Pasighat, Arunachal Pradesh – 791102 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Rajiv Gandhi University) Code No. APE00564	The Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.09.02.2010 received in ERC dt.07.02.2010 in response to ERC Notice No.2977 dt.14.01.2010 and decided that Notice u/s 14(3) (b) may be issued giving 30 days for the following deficiencies. Certified Copy of registered land documents. Approved Building Plan from the Competent authority giving khata No., Plot No., Total Area and Built up area. Building Completion Certificate where the proposed B.Ed. Course will be opened with Plot No., Khata No, built –up area, total area, khesera No. from the Competent State Govt. Authority not submitted.

1^st Supplementary

ER–105.4(I)	Appeal Cases: Cases under process on being remanded back/ Reversed by the Appeal Committee.
ER–105.4(I).1	Parmarth Institute of Teacher’s Education, Vill – Bamhour, PO – Shivsagar, Taluka – Sasaram, Dist – Rohtas, Bihar – 821111 (B.Ed) (Private) (Veer Kunwar University) Code No. APE001191	The Committee considered the reply dt. 20.02.2010 received in this office on 24.02.2010 in response to ERC LOI dt. 30.01.2010 along with relevant documents and decided that Notice u/s 14(3) (b) may be issued giving 30 days for the following deficiencies. (i) Principal’s experience is not submitted. (ii) The staff is paid Consolidated salary, which is not as per NCTE norms.
ER–105.4(I).2	Chaurasia Raj Kishore College, Vill/Po./City – Hajipur, Dist – Vaishali, Bihar – 844101 (B.Ed) (Private) (B.R. Ambedkar University) (Code No. APE00884)	The Committee considered the reply dt. 23.02.2010 received in this office on 02.03.2010 in response to ERC Notice dt. 30.01.2010 along with relevant documents and decided that Notice u/s 14(3) (b) may be issued giving 30 days for the following deficiencies. (i) The institution had submitted the Building Completion Certificate issued on 31.01.2008, LTC issued on 10.12.08, Affidavit submitted on 5.12.09, which states the built up area as 1612.52 sqm, whereas the land documents registered on 04.11.2009 shows the covered area as (71.72 sqmt.). The institution is required to clarify this discrepancy.
ER–103.4(II)	Appeal Cases: Cases Rejected by the Appeal Committee and confirmed the ERC order.
ER–105.4(II).1	Millat Teacher’s Training College, Vill – Bhowara (Madhubani), Rahika, PO – Bhowara, Bihar – 847212 (B.P.Ed.) (L.N. Mithila University) (Code No.APE01007).	The Committee noted that the appeal was rejected and the ERC’s order dated 26.10.2009 was confirmed.
ER–105.9	Miscellaneous Cases
ER–105.9.1	Sarif B.Ed. College, Baigachhipara,Golam Rahaman Lane College Campus, Santipur, Nadia, West Bengal, Pin – 741 404 (B.Ed.) (Private) (University of Kalyani) (Code No.APE001156).	The Committee considered the case of the institution and decided that action under section 17 of the NCTE Act to be initiated on the institution. Further, the two VT members. (i) Dr. Akhil Chandra Biswal and (ii) Dr. S.M. Ali Imam be dropped from the VT panel. The following VT Members are deputed for action u/s 17 :- Prof. B. N. Panda Reader in Education, Regional Institute of Education, NCERT, Sachivalaya Marg, Bhubaneswar-751022 Prof. N.B. Biswas Deptt. of Education, Assam Univ., Silchar-788011
ER–105.9.2	Jamshedpur Women’s College, Bistupur, Jamshedpur, Jharkhand - 831001 (Private) (B.Ed.) (Code No. APE00410)	The Committee considered the case of the institution and decided that a letter may be sent to the Registrar, Jharkhand University for a report on the allegations endorsing a copy to the Principal of the institution to the alleged irregularity and also a letter to the complainant asking for confirmation of the complaint.
ER–105.9.3	File No. ERC/06-2/OR/2004/IV/ (Complaint received against the institution) A letter No. 039 dated 22^nd January 2010 received from Old Students Association, Radhanath Institute of Advanced Studies in Education, Cuttack – 753 002, Orissa forwarded by Chairperson, NCTE to Chairperson, ERC regarding position of teacher education in the State of Orissa – An Appeal for maintenance of quality in conformity to NCTE norms.	The Committee noted that a complaint dt.22.01.2010 received from Old Students Association, Radhanath Institute of Advanced Studies in Education, Cuttack-753002, Orissa forwarded by Chairperson, NCTE Hqrs to Chairperson NCTE, ERC regarding position of teacher education in the State of Orissa –An Appeal for maintenance of quality in conformity to NCTE norms and decided that letter to be written to the concerned institutions to explain the irregularities, alleged.
ER–105.9.4	File No. ERC/06-2/OR/2004/IV/ Representation received for relaxation in NCTE norms. A letter dated 13^th February 2010 received from All Orissa College Physical Education Teacher Association, Cuttack	The Committee noted that a letter dated 13^th February 2010 received from All Orissa College Physical Education Teacher Association, Cuttack and decided that the applicant may be informed that power of relaxation is available with the Chairperson-NCTE with the recommendation of State Govt.
ER–105.9.5	ERC/06-2/WB/2010 The NCTE-HQrs vide Fax No.F. No. 62-5/2008/NCTE/N&S/11529 dated 5^th March 2010 had informed that the competent authority ad decided to accord approval for a ‘Bridge Course’ in the State of West Bengal in the order to resolve the problem of consequent upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Division Bench of Calcutta High Court in the matter of Tulsi Bakshi and others wherein the qualifications given for one year PTT course offered by various teacher training institutions in the State of West Bengal were not considered equivalent to the D.Ed course in the absence of NCTE’s recognition to the course and directed to consider the application for the said Bridge Course on receipt of the same formally from the Government of West Bengal and process further for according approval of the ERC for recognition of the said course in the light of the observations conveyed to the Govt. of West Bengal vide letter dtd 03.03.2010. It had further stated that it would not be necessary for the Govt. of West Bengal to submit the application online and the provisions as are required for processing of regular applications, seeking recognition of teacher education courses by the individual institutions, would also not apply in this case. The Secretary, West Bengal Board of Primary Education had sent a letter to ERC dated 8^th March 2010 requesting to accord approval in the matter of conducting the said Bridge Course.	The Committee while considering the case noted the following letters/representation received from the NCTE Hqrs./State Govt.:- (i) A Fax letter No. F.No.62-5/ 2008/NCTE/N&S/11529 dated 5^th March 2010 received from the NCTE Hqrs. addressed to the RD, ERC whereby it has been informed that the Chairperson, NCTE- Hqrs in exerercise of the powers vested under clause 11 of the NCTE Regulations, 2009 has approved the proposed Bridge course for the PTT candidate through the West Bengal Board of Primary Education (WBBPE) by ODL mode. (ii) A fax letter No. F.No.62-5/ 2008/NCTE/N&S/11529 dated 5^th March 2010 addressed to Shri Vikram Sen, Secretary to the Govt. of West Bengal, School Education Department whereby the approval of the competent authority in NCTE is conveyed to the Govt. of West Bengal to conduct a ‘Bridge-Course’ of one year duration for PTTI trainees in the State of West Bengal through ODL Mode subject to certain conditions. (iii) Letter No. 218/BPE/2010 dt.8.3.2010 received from Shri D.Mandal, Secretary, West Bengal Board of Primary Education requesting therein to accord approval in the matter of conducting the said Bridge course as directed by the NCTE, Hqrs New Delhi. The Committee considered all these letters/communications received from the NCTE Hqrs. and the West Bengal Board of Primary Education. The Committee decided to give in principal approval to the proposal keeping in view the approval of the Chairperson, NCTE-Hqrs for conducting the Bridge Course for the PTT candidates through the West Bengal Board of Primary Education (WBBPE) through ODL mode. However formal orders would be issued after receipt of the formal application and details of the said Bridge Course from the Government of West Bengal as per the letter No.62-5/ 2008/NCTE/N&S/11529 dated 5^th March 2010 addressed to Shri Vikram Sen, Secretary to the Govt. of West Bengal, School Education Department by the NCTE Hqrs.
ER–105.9.6	Jharkhand Teacher’s Training College, Jhumritelaiya, Dist- Koderma, Jharkhand - 825409 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Viniba Bhave University)	The Committee decided that action u/s 17 of the NCTE Act to be expedited urgently.
ER–105.9.7	Education College, Vill – Basantapur, PO - Basantapur, Dist.-Murshidabad, West Bengal- 742 406 (M.Ed.)(University of Kalyani) (Code No.APE001093).	The Committee decided that action under Section 17 may be initiated. The following VT Members are deputed for action u/s 17 :- Prof. B. N. Panda, Bhubaneswar-751022 Prof. N.B. Biswas, Silchar-788011
ER–105.9.8	F. No. ERC/07/Gen/2010/ Inspection of institutions u/s 14/15/17 of the NCTE Act. The ERC in its 104^th meeting held on 28^th-29^th January 2010 had decided the name of experts to be deputed to particular institutions for inspection u/s 14/15/17 of the NCTE Act.	As advised by the NCTE Hqrs., the list of 22 experts under ‘A’ are dropped from VT list / panel. Six experts under ‘B’ will not be deputed in VT till their credentials are verified in consultation with NCTE-Hqrs. Out of nine experts suggested under list ‘C’ for inclusion, four are already in the panel. Remaining five may also be included.